The value of a James Garfield dollar coin depends on whether it’s a Presidential Dollar (issued starting in 2007) or a rare gold dollar from 1881.
These coins, issued as part of the Presidential Dollar series, typically have a face value of $1. However, collector’s versions in high grades can sell for slightly more, usually in the range of $4-12. You can find these coins for sale from online retailers like Littleton Coin Company, [Coins of America] , and on [eBay] for around $2.75 to $6.00, depending on the condition and if they’re sold individually or in sets. Uncirculated sets containing coins from multiple mints can be found for about $10-12.
A much rarer and more valuable option is the 1881 gold dollar coin, also featuring James Garfield. According to the NGC Price Guide, a circulated 1881 Gold Dollar can be worth between $225 and $475. Pristine, uncirculated examples can sell for as much as $48,500. Note that these are gold coins and distinct from the more common Presidential Dollars. You might find some sellers listing the Presidential Dollar using language that implies it’s an 1881 coin (likely referring to Garfield’s year in office), but the composition of the Presidential Dollars is manganese brass clad copper, not gold. If you are looking for this older, rarer coin, it’s crucial to verify the mint date and material.
Some James Garfield dollar coins (typically Presidential Dollars) have errors, which can increase their value to collectors. Examples include:
- Planchette Errors : Coins struck on defective blanks or with missing portions of the planchette. One such coin with a missing rim inscription was offered for $175 on [eBay].
- Doubled Edge Lettering : These errors can be either overlapped (doubled lettering in the same direction) or inverted (doubled lettering in opposite directions).
- Dye Errors : Coins with dye errors or “wondering eyes” can also fetch higher prices. Examples were offered on [eBay] for $20 and on [eBay] for $100.
- Other Errors : Other uncertified error coins have been listed on [eBay] for as much as $1500, described as “EXTREME RARE PEICE”.
You can find James Garfield dollar coins for sale on:
- [eBay] : A popular online marketplace with a wide range of offerings, including both Presidential and rare gold coins, and error coins.
- Littleton Coin Company : Offers James Garfield Presidential Dollars, including sets, in uncirculated collectible condition.
- [Coins of America] : Sells James Garfield Presidential Dollars individually or as part of a collection.
Before purchasing, it is important to carefully examine the coin’s condition and verify its authenticity, especially when dealing with rare and expensive coins. Consider buying from reputable sellers with good reviews.
Where is the mint mark on the James Garfield dollar coin?
The traditional inscriptions “E Pluribus Unum,” the date of issuance and the mint mark have been moved to the edge of the coin, making it unique among circulating coins. The reverse features a stunning image of the Statue of Liberty.
Is my $1 dollar coin worth anything?
Thanks for asking. Modern dollar coin programs emphasize education, commemoration, and design innovation over circulation. While face value remains $1, collector versions in high grades can command $4-12 premiums, and special mint products offer additional collecting opportunities.
How much is a 1881 $1 gold coin worth?
Good point! According to the NGC Price Guide, as of August 2025, a Gold Dollar Coin from 1881 in circulated condition is worth between $225 and $475.