The James Buchanan Presidential dollar coin has captured the attention of collectors and numismatists since its release in 2010. Understanding the james buchanan gold dollar coin value requires examining various factors including condition, mint marks, and potential minting errors that can dramatically affect worth. While standard examples trade for modest amounts, rare error coins can command premium prices exceeding $1,000.
Overview of the James Buchanan Presidential Dollar
The James Buchanan Presidential dollar was the 15th coin released in the Presidential $1 Coin Program, which ran from 2007 to 2016. This program honored deceased U.S. presidents in the order they served, with four new designs released each year. Buchanan, who served as the 15th President from 1857 to 1861, was commemorated in 2010 alongside Millard Fillmore, Franklin Pierce, and Abraham Lincoln.
Key Specifications
- Composition: 88.5% copper, 6% zinc, 3.5% manganese, 2% nickel
- Weight: 8.1 grams
- Diameter: 26.5 mm
- Edge: Lettered with date, mintmark, and “E Pluribus Unum”
- Designer: Susan Gamble (obverse), Don Everhart (reverse)
The coin features Buchanan’s portrait on the obverse with the Statue of Liberty on the reverse, maintaining consistency with other Presidential dollars in the series.
Standard James Buchanan Gold Dollar Coin Value
When evaluating james buchanan gold dollar coin value, collectors must first understand the baseline worth of standard, error-free examples. The value depends heavily on the coin’s condition and mint of origin.
Philadelphia Mint (P Mintmark)
The 2010 James Buchanan Presidential dollar coin from the Philadelphia mint carries a “P” mintmark on its edge. In uncirculated condition, these coins typically have a retail value of approximately $3.50. This modest premium over face value reflects the coin’s limited collector demand and relatively high mintage numbers.
Key factors affecting Philadelphia mint values:
- Circulated condition: Face value ($1.00)
- Uncirculated condition: $3.50
- Higher grades (MS-65 and above): $4.00-$6.00
Denver Mint (D Mintmark)
Similarly, the 2010 James Buchanan Presidential dollar coin from the Denver mint, identifiable by its “D” mintmark, maintains comparable values to its Philadelphia counterpart. Uncirculated examples also retail for around $3.50.
Denver mint value breakdown:
- Circulated examples: $1.00 (face value)
- Uncirculated condition: $3.50
- Premium uncirculated grades: $4.00-$6.00
San Francisco Proof (S Mintmark)
The 2010-S proof James Buchanan dollar coin represents the premium version produced specifically for collectors. These coins undergo a special minting process that creates mirror-like surfaces and frosted devices, resulting in superior visual appeal.
A 2010-S proof James Buchanan dollar coin in PR 65 condition is worth approximately $6.00. Higher proof grades can command slightly more:
- PR-65: $6.00
- PR-67: $8.00-$10.00
- PR-69: $12.00-$15.00
- PR-70 (perfect grade): $20.00-$25.00
Error Coins: Where Values Skyrocket
The most significant factor affecting james buchanan gold dollar coin value involves minting errors. The James Buchanan Presidential dollar has two known major errors that can dramatically increase a coin’s worth from a few dollars to hundreds or even thousands.
Missing Edge Lettering Error
The most valuable and sought-after error involves missing edge lettering. A small number of James Buchanan dollars were struck without the required edge inscriptions, which should include:
- The date (2010)
- The mintmark (P or D)
- “E Pluribus Unum”
- “In God We Trust”
This error occurred when coins bypassed the edge lettering process entirely, creating what collectors call “plain edge” Presidential dollars.
Value ranges for missing edge lettering:
- Lower grades (circulated): $300-$500
- Uncirculated examples: $800-$1,200
- High-grade specimens: $1,000+
- Certified examples: Premium of 10-20% above raw coins
The rarity of this error cannot be overstated. Even lower-grade examples of this error can fetch several hundred dollars when properly authenticated, while uncirculated examples have sold for over $1,000 at auction.
Double Edge Lettering Error
Another valuable error occurs when coins receive extra edge lettering, creating a double-struck appearance on the edge inscriptions. This happens when a coin goes through the edge lettering process twice, either due to mechanical malfunction or human error.
Double edge lettering values:
- Circulated condition: $150-$300
- Uncirculated condition: $400-$700
- High grades with clear doubling: $800-$1,000
The value depends significantly on how clearly visible the doubling appears and the overall condition of the coin.
Authentication and Grading Importance
Given the substantial value difference between standard coins and error varieties, professional authentication becomes crucial when dealing with potential error coins. Reputable third-party grading services provide essential verification services.
Recommended Grading Services
- Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS)
- Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC)
- ANACS (American Numismatic Association Certification Service)
These services examine coins under magnification, verify authenticity, and assign grades that directly impact market value. It’s crucial to have any potential error coins authenticated by these professional services before attempting to sell or establish value.
Benefits of Professional Grading
- Authentication verification: Confirms genuine errors versus post-mint damage
- Grade assignment: Provides standardized condition assessment
- Market acceptance: Certified coins command higher prices
- Protection: Sealed holders prevent handling damage
- Resale value: Easier to sell certified coins
Factors Affecting James Buchanan Gold Dollar Coin Value
Several elements beyond errors influence the james buchanan gold dollar coin value:
Condition and Grade
The coin’s physical condition dramatically affects value. Professional grading services use a 70-point scale:
- MS-60 to MS-62: Basic uncirculated condition
- MS-63 to MS-65: Choice uncirculated with good eye appeal
- MS-66 to MS-68: Gem uncirculated with exceptional quality
- MS-69 to MS-70: Perfect or near-perfect specimens
Market Demand
Presidential dollars generally experience modest collector demand compared to other series. However, error coins create significant interest among specialists and error coin collectors.
Mintage Numbers
The James Buchanan dollar had substantial mintage figures:
- Philadelphia: 36,820,000
- Denver: 36,540,000
- San Francisco Proof: 2,224,627
High mintages typically suppress values for standard examples.
Historical Significance
Buchanan’s controversial presidency, particularly his handling of pre-Civil War tensions, may influence long-term collector interest, though this factor currently has minimal impact on values.
Investment Considerations
When considering james buchanan gold dollar coin value as an investment, several factors merit attention:
Pros of Collecting
- Error coins offer significant upside potential
- Low entry cost for standard examples
- Part of complete Presidential series
- Potential for future discoveries of new error types
Cons and Risks
- Limited demand for standard examples
- High mintages suppress common coin values
- Authentication costs for potential errors
- Market volatility for error coins
Market Trends and Future Outlook
The james buchanan gold dollar coin value market shows distinct patterns:
Current Trends
- Stable prices for standard examples
- Strong demand for authenticated errors
- Growing awareness of Presidential dollar errors
- Increased scrutiny of potential error coins
Future Considerations
- Potential for new error discoveries
- Possible increased interest as series ages
- Impact of precious metal prices on collector interest
- Evolution of grading standards and technology
Conclusion
The james buchanan gold dollar coin value ranges dramatically from face value to over $1,000, depending primarily on the presence of minting errors. While standard examples trade for modest premiums around $3.50 in uncirculated condition, error coins—particularly those with missing edge lettering—command substantial premiums.
For collectors and investors, the key lies in understanding the difference between standard examples and valuable errors. Professional authentication remains essential for any coin suspected of having errors, as the value difference between genuine errors and damaged coins can be enormous.
Whether collecting for historical interest or investment potential, the James Buchanan Presidential dollar offers opportunities at various price points. Standard examples provide affordable entry into Presidential dollar collecting, while error coins present the possibility of significant returns for those lucky enough to discover them.
The market for these coins continues evolving, with error varieties maintaining strong collector interest despite the general Presidential dollar series experiencing modest demand. As awareness grows and more collectors examine their coins carefully, additional error varieties may surface, potentially creating new opportunities in the james buchanan gold dollar coin value market.
Why is the 1984 $1 coin rare?
Importantly, with the Maklouf portrait of the Queen introduced in 1985, the 1984 $1 is the only issued $1 bearing the Machin portrait. Thus, it is an utterly unique type in the Australian decimal series!