The value of an 1886 five-dollar gold coin (also known as a half eagle) can vary significantly based on its condition and the mint where it was produced.
Here’s a breakdown:
- Circulated condition:
– An 1886 half eagle from the Philadelphia Mint (no mintmark) is worth between $915 and $995.
– An 1886-S half eagle from the San Francisco Mint is worth between $910 and $990.
- Pristine, uncirculated condition:
– An 1886 half eagle from the Philadelphia Mint in pristine condition could be worth as much as $25,500.
– An 1886-S half eagle from the San Francisco Mint in pristine condition could be worth as much as $13,000.
- Specific examples from online marketplaces:
– An 1886-S graded MS63 by PCGS sold for $1,255.00.
– An 1886-S graded MS64 by PCGS with a CAC label sold for $1,092.00.
– An 1886-S graded AU-58 by NGC sold for $1,250.00.
Key factors that influence a coin’s value:
- Rarity and Mintage Numbers: Coins with lower mintage numbers or fewer surviving examples are generally more valuable.
- Condition and Grading: The better the condition of the coin (less wear, more original luster), the higher its grade and usually its value.
- Precious Metal Content: The gold content of the 1886 five-dollar coin gives it an intrinsic value, but the numismatic (collectible) value often surpasses this, [according to Hero Bullion] and [Bullion Shark].
- Market Factors and Investor Demand: Like any collectible, the value of a coin can fluctuate based on current market demand and collector interest.
To get an accurate appraisal of your 1886 five-dollar gold coin, it is recommended to:
- Consult a reputable coin dealer: Seek out a coin dealer who belongs to professional numismatic organizations like the American Numismatic Association or the Professional Numismatists Guild.
- Consider professional grading services: Companies like NGC or PCGS can provide an unbiased evaluation of your coin’s condition and assign a numerical grade, which can significantly impact its value.
- Use price guides and catalogs: Resources like the Red Book offer detailed pricing information based on various conditions and can help you understand current market trends.
Important Note: Avoid cleaning or altering your coin, as this can severely diminish its value.
How much is an 1886 $5 gold coin worth?
According to the NGC Price Guide, as of August 2025, a Half Eagle from 1886 in circulated condition is worth between $915 and $995. However, on the open market 1886 5 Dollar Coins in pristine, uncirculated condition sell for as much as $25500.
How much is a 1886 gold dollar worth?
Good point! 1886 Gold Dollar Coin Value
According to the NGC Price Guide, as of August 2025, a Gold Dollar Coin from 1886 in circulated condition is worth between $225 and $475. However, on the open market 1886 Gold Dollars in pristine, uncirculated condition sell for as much as $15250.
What is the mintage of the 1886 S $5 gold coin?
The mintage for the 1886-S $5 Gold Liberty coin is recorded at approximately 3,648,000 pieces. This relatively high mintage makes the 1886-S half eagle one of the more accessible dates in the Liberty Head series; however, finding examples in high grades, such as AU (About Uncirculated), can be quite a challenge.