The value of a 1937 5 cent coin, also known as a Buffalo Nickel, depends on its condition, mint mark, and any potential errors.
- Circulated condition: A 1937 Buffalo Nickel in circulated condition typically ranges from $1 to $10. According to the [NGC Price Guide] , as of August 2025, it’s worth between $0.50 and $20.
- Uncirculated condition: Uncirculated examples can be worth significantly more, often fetching between $20 and $50. Coins in pristine, uncirculated condition can sell for as much as $8,000.
- No Mint Mark (Philadelphia Mint): These are the most common and generally have lower values, ranging from $9 to $30,000 depending on the condition.
- D Mint Mark (Denver Mint): These are rarer than Philadelphia issues and may be worth more, [according to Bullion Shark] . In circulated condition, they typically range from $1 to $10, while uncirculated examples can reach $70 or more.
- S Mint Mark (San Francisco Mint): Coins with the “S” mint mark are also rarer than Philadelphia issues and highly valued, especially in higher grades. Their value can be similar to that of Denver mint coins.
- [1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo Nickel]: This is the most famous and sought-after error variety, caused by over-polishing of the die at the Denver Mint which resulted in the bison appearing to have only three legs. These are very rare and can reach values of $150,000, [according to Bullion Exchanges] . Even in lower grades, these nickels can fetch $600–$1,000+, according to Bullion Shark.
In summary
The value of your 1937 5 cent coin depends heavily on its condition and whether it has a mint mark or an error. It’s always recommended to consult with a reputable coin dealer or professional grader for an accurate valuation.
What year is the rarest 5 cent coin?
From my experience, Australia 1972 5 Cent Coin Circulated. This is an honest example of the rarest Australian 5 cent coin issued into circulation.