One of the most intriguing moral dilemmas in Lies of P revolves around a seemingly simple question: should I give gold coin fruit to black cat? This decision, while appearing minor at first glance, carries significant weight throughout your playthrough and can dramatically alter your gaming experience. Understanding the full implications of this choice is crucial for players who want to make an informed decision that aligns with their preferred gameplay style and narrative outcomes.
Understanding the Black Cat and Red Fox Characters
Before diving into whether you should give gold coin fruit to black cat, it’s essential to understand who these characters are and their role in the Lies of P universe. The Black Cat and Red Fox are mysterious figures who appear early in your journey, presenting themselves as enigmatic allies with their own agenda.
These characters operate as a duo, working together on various missions throughout the game world. Their relationship with the protagonist, Pinocchio, can develop in multiple directions depending on your choices, particularly regarding the gold coin fruit decision. The Black Cat, in particular, serves as a pivotal character whose fate directly impacts several storylines and optional content within the game.
The Significance of Gold Coin Fruit
The gold coin fruit itself represents more than just an in-game item. It symbolizes trust, cooperation, and the player’s willingness to engage with morally ambiguous characters. When the Black Cat requests this fruit, players must weigh the immediate benefits against potential long-term consequences, making this one of the game’s most thought-provoking moments.
Positive Outcomes: Why You Should Give Gold Coin Fruit to Black Cat
Building Trust and Friendship
When considering should I give gold coin fruit to black cat, the most immediate positive outcome involves building trust and establishing friendship with both the Black Cat and Red Fox. This relationship development opens up unique dialogue options and provides deeper insight into the game’s lore and character motivations.
By choosing to give the fruit, you demonstrate Pinocchio’s capacity for trust and cooperation, which aligns with certain character development paths. This decision reinforces themes of humanity and compassion that run throughout the Lies of P narrative, potentially influencing your character’s growth and the story’s direction.
Avoiding the Optional Boss Battle
One of the most significant practical benefits of giving the gold coin fruit to black cat is avoiding a challenging optional boss fight later in the game. The Black Cat can become a formidable opponent if your relationship deteriorates, and this boss battle is notoriously difficult for many players.
For those who prefer to focus on the main storyline or who find themselves struggling with the game’s combat difficulty, avoiding this confrontation can be a strategic advantage. The boss fight, while optional, can be time-consuming and resource-intensive, requiring specific strategies and potentially multiple attempts to overcome.
Exclusive Rewards and Items
Players who choose to give the fruit receive exclusive rewards including the Quixotic Record and a unique gesture. These items serve both functional and cosmetic purposes:
- The Quixotic Record: This item can affect your humanity score, which influences various aspects of gameplay and story outcomes
- Special Gesture: Provides a unique animation that can be used for character expression and online interactions
- Potential Humanity Score Impact: The decision may contribute to your overall humanity rating, affecting certain endings and character interactions
Narrative Implications and Story Development
Giving the gold coin fruit allows the Black Cat and Red Fox to pursue their mission for the Alchemists. While this initially seems beneficial, it leads to complex plot developments that add depth to the overall narrative. This choice enables players to experience a specific storyline branch that provides insight into the game’s political intrigue and faction dynamics.
The resulting events, including the attack on Hotel Krat and Geppetto’s kidnapping, create a more intricate web of consequences that some players find more engaging than the alternative path. This decision demonstrates how seemingly small choices can have far-reaching implications in Lies of P.
Negative Consequences: Why You Might Reconsider
Enabling Harmful Actions
While giving the fruit builds trust, it also enables the Black Cat and Red Fox to carry out missions that result in significant harm. The attack on Hotel Krat and Geppetto’s kidnapping are direct consequences of your decision to help them. Players who prioritize protecting innocent characters and maintaining stability might find these outcomes troubling.
This moral complexity is intentional, forcing players to grapple with the unintended consequences of their seemingly benevolent actions. The game challenges players to consider whether helping individuals is worth the potential harm to the broader community.
Missing Combat Experience
For players who enjoy the game’s combat system and seek challenging encounters, avoiding the Black Cat boss fight means missing out on a unique and rewarding battle experience. This optional boss provides distinct mechanics and strategies that can enhance your understanding of the combat system.
Additionally, overcoming challenging boss fights often provides a sense of accomplishment and progression that some players value highly. The Black Cat boss fight offers specific patterns and techniques that can improve your overall combat skills for other encounters.
Alternative Path: Refusing to Give the Fruit
Initiating the Boss Battle
If you decide not to give the gold coin fruit to black cat, you’ll eventually face him in combat. This boss fight presents unique challenges and requires specific strategies to overcome successfully. The battle serves as a test of your combat skills and provides an alternative narrative path.
The boss fight itself is well-designed, offering multiple phases and requiring players to adapt their strategies throughout the encounter. For combat enthusiasts, this represents valuable content that shouldn’t be missed.
Obtaining Black Cat’s Mask
Regardless of your choice regarding the gold coin fruit, you’ll ultimately obtain the Black Cat’s Mask. However, the method of acquisition differs significantly:
- Through friendship: Received as a gift or reward for cooperation
- Through combat: Obtained after defeating the Black Cat in battle
The mask serves both aesthetic and potential functional purposes, making it a valuable item regardless of how you acquire it.
Impact on Red Fox Interactions
One crucial consideration when deciding should I give gold coin fruit to black cat involves the Red Fox’s reaction to your choices. If you choose to fight and defeat the Black Cat, the Red Fox will become hostile in future encounters, seeking revenge for her companion’s death.
This hostility blocks off potential dialogue options, quest lines, and character development opportunities with the Red Fox. Players interested in exploring all character interactions and storylines should carefully consider this consequence.
Strategic Considerations for Different Playthroughs
First Playthrough Recommendations
For players experiencing Lies of P for the first time, giving the gold coin fruit to black cat often provides a more accessible experience. This choice:
- Reduces overall combat difficulty by avoiding an optional boss
- Provides clearer narrative progression
- Offers immediate rewards and positive reinforcement
- Allows focus on main story elements without additional complications
Subsequent Playthroughs and Completionist Goals
Players pursuing multiple playthroughs or completionist objectives might want to experience both paths. The decision regarding should I give gold coin fruit to black cat can vary between playthroughs to:
- Experience all available content and boss fights
- Explore different narrative outcomes
- Test various combat strategies and character builds
- Achieve different endings and story variations
Character Build Considerations
Your character build and playstyle preferences should influence your decision:
- Combat-focused builds: Might benefit from the additional boss fight experience
- Story-focused players: May prefer the narrative complexity of giving the fruit
- Completionist builds: Should consider both options across multiple playthroughs
Long-term Consequences and Ending Implications
The choice of whether to give the gold coin fruit to black cat extends beyond immediate consequences, potentially affecting:
Humanity Score Impact
Your humanity score influences various aspects of the game, including:
- Available dialogue options
- Character interactions and relationships
- Potential ending variations
- Access to specific content and areas
Faction Relationships
The decision affects your standing with different factions within the game world, potentially opening or closing certain questlines and interactions based on your choice.
Character Development Arc
Pinocchio’s character development can follow different trajectories depending on this decision, influencing how other characters perceive and interact with you throughout the remainder of the game.
Making Your Decision: Factors to Consider
When ultimately deciding should I give gold coin fruit to black cat, consider these key factors:
Personal Playstyle Preferences:
- Do you enjoy challenging boss fights?
- Are you more interested in narrative complexity or combat encounters?
- How important are immediate rewards versus long-term consequences?
Story Priorities:
- Do you prefer to help individual characters even if it leads to broader consequences?
- Are you interested in exploring morally complex scenarios?
- How important is maintaining access to all character interactions?
Gameplay Goals:
- Are you pursuing a completionist playthrough?
- Do you plan multiple playthroughs to experience different outcomes?
- How does this decision align with your overall character build and strategy?
Conclusion
The question of should I give gold coin fruit to black cat represents one of Lies of P’s most nuanced moral dilemmas. There is no universally “correct” answer, as the best choice depends entirely on your personal preferences, playstyle, and narrative priorities.
Giving the fruit offers immediate benefits, builds relationships, and avoids a challenging boss fight, but enables harmful actions with far-reaching consequences. Refusing creates combat opportunities and maintains moral clarity but closes off certain character interactions and storylines.
Ultimately, this decision exemplifies the game’s commitment to meaningful choice and consequence, challenging players to consider the complex implications of their actions. Whether you choose to give the gold coin fruit to black cat or not, both paths offer valuable experiences that contribute to the rich, morally complex world of Lies of P.
Consider your priorities, embrace the consequences of your choice, and remember that the beauty of this decision lies not in finding the “right” answer, but in engaging thoughtfully with the moral complexity that makes Lies of P such a compelling gaming experience.
Do you get humanity for killing the Black Cat?
From my experience, There’s no humanity from him regardless of how you deal with him.