The 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar coin value represents one of the most intriguing chapters in modern American numismatics. After an 18-year hiatus, the Susan B. Anthony dollar made its surprising return in 1999, creating unique opportunities for collectors and investors alike. Understanding the factors that influence these coins’ values can help you determine whether you’re holding a common dollar or a valuable treasure.
Historical Context of the 1999 Susan B Anthony Dollar
The Susan B. Anthony dollar series originally ran from 1979 to 1981, but poor public reception led to its discontinuation. However, in 1999, the U.S. Mint faced an unexpected shortage of dollar coins in circulation. Rather than immediately introduce the planned Sacagawea dollar (which wouldn’t debut until 2000), the Mint decided to produce additional Susan B. Anthony dollars using the existing dies and specifications.
This decision created a unique situation in American coinage history. The 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar coin value is significantly influenced by this 18-year production gap, making these coins particularly interesting to collectors who appreciate their historical significance and relative scarcity compared to other modern dollar coins.
Basic Value Guidelines for 1999 Susan B Anthony Dollars
Circulated Condition Values
For coins that have seen everyday use, the 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar coin value remains relatively modest but still above face value:
- Average circulated condition (XF-AU): $1.50 – $3.00
- NGC Price Guide estimates: $1.05 – $1.35 for typical circulated examples
- Well-worn specimens: Often trade close to face value at $1.00 – $1.25
These values reflect the coin’s status as a modern issue with substantial mintage numbers, though the 18-year gap does provide some premium over face value.
Factors Affecting Circulated Values
Several factors influence the 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar coin value in circulated grades:
- Wear patterns: Coins with minimal wear command higher premiums
- Surface quality: Examples free from major scratches or damage are more desirable
- Strike quality: Well-struck examples with sharp details bring better prices
- Eye appeal: Coins with attractive toning or luster remnants may exceed typical ranges
Uncirculated 1999 Susan B Anthony Dollar Values
The real excitement in 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar coin value emerges when examining uncirculated specimens, particularly those in higher grades.
Philadelphia Mint (1999-P) Values
1999-P Susan B. Anthony dollars offer varying value potential based on their preservation:
- Basic uncirculated (MS60-MS63): $3 – $8
- Choice uncirculated (MS64-MS65): $10 – $20
- Gem uncirculated (MS66-MS67): $25 – $75
- Superb examples (MS68+): $100 – $700
The highest-grade examples have achieved remarkable prices, with pristine specimens selling for $700 or more at auction. These exceptional values reflect both the coin’s quality and the strong collector demand for perfect examples.
Denver Mint (1999-D) Values
1999-D Susan B. Anthony dollars generally command higher premiums than their Philadelphia counterparts due to lower mintage figures:
- Typical uncirculated grades: $15 – $25
- Premium uncirculated (MS65-MS67): $30 – $100
- Top grades (MS68+): $100 – $600
The Denver Mint pieces benefit from their relative scarcity, with uncirculated examples having sold for up to $600 in top grades. This premium reflects both lower production numbers and strong collector interest in completing date and mintmark sets.
Proof Coin Values
1999-S Proof Susan B Anthony Dollars
Proof coins represent the pinnacle of the 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar coin value spectrum for regular strikes. These specially made coins were struck at the San Francisco Mint exclusively for collectors:
- Standard proof condition (PR65-PR67): $20 – $40
- Deep cameo proofs (PR68-PR69): $50 – $100
- Perfect proofs (PR70): $100 – $200+
Proof Packaging Considerations
The value of proof coins is significantly influenced by their original packaging:
- Complete original government packaging: Adds 20-30% premium
- Certificate of authenticity: Essential for maximum value
- Undisturbed coins: Those never removed from packaging command highest prices
- Sets vs. individual coins: Complete proof sets may carry additional premiums
Error Coins: Hidden Treasures
Error coins represent some of the most valuable examples in the 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar coin value category. These minting mistakes create unique collectibles that command substantial premiums.
Major Error Types and Values
Doubled Ear Variety
- Description: Visible doubling on Susan B. Anthony’s ear
- 1999-P examples: $80 – $150+ in high grades
- Identification: Requires magnification to confirm doubling
- Rarity: Relatively scarce but not extremely rare
Misaligned Die Errors
- 1999-D specimens: $50 – $100+ depending on severity
- Characteristics: Design elements appear shifted or rotated
- Value factors: Degree of misalignment affects pricing
- Authentication: Professional grading recommended
Off-Center Strikes
- Value range: $50 – $300+ based on offset percentage
- Most valuable: 10-25% off-center strikes with full date
- Both P and D mints: Errors possible from either facility
- Dramatic examples: Extreme off-center strikes bring highest premiums
Double Struck in Collar
- 1999-D examples: $200 – $300+ or more
- Rarity: Among the scarcer error types
- Appearance: Overlapping images from multiple strikes
- Authentication: Professional certification essential
Struck on Wrong Planchets
- Sacagawea planchet errors: Extremely valuable
- Documented sale: MS64 PCGS example sold for $1,020 in 2020
- Rarity: Among the most sought-after errors
- Authentication: Requires expert verification
Grading and Authentication
Understanding coin grading is crucial for accurately assessing 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar coin value. Professional grading services like PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) and NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Corporation) provide standardized assessments that significantly impact market values.
Grading Scale Significance
- MS60-MS62: Basic uncirculated with noticeable marks
- MS63-MS64: Choice uncirculated with fewer distractions
- MS65-MS67: Gem quality with minimal imperfections
- MS68-MS70: Superb to perfect specimens commanding premium prices
Authentication Benefits
Professional authentication provides several advantages:
- Market confidence: Certified coins trade more readily
- Value protection: Grading protects against counterfeits
- Condition verification: Eliminates grading disputes
- Insurance purposes: Certified grades support insurance claims
Market Factors Affecting Values
Supply and Demand Dynamics
The 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar coin value is influenced by several market factors:
Collector Interest
- Strong demand from type collectors
- Date and mintmark set completers
- Susan B. Anthony dollar specialists
- Modern coin enthusiasts
Market Availability
- Limited quantities in highest grades
- Error coins remain scarce
- Proof coins have finite populations
- Raw vs. certified specimens
Investment Considerations
While not typically considered investment-grade coins, certain 1999 Susan B Anthony dollars offer potential:
- High-grade examples: MS67+ specimens show appreciation potential
- Error varieties: Rare errors may continue gaining value
- Perfect proofs: PR70 examples have strong collector demand
- Market timing: Values fluctuate with overall coin market conditions
Tips for Collectors and Sellers
Maximizing Your Coin’s Value
To optimize your 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar coin value:
- Proper storage: Use appropriate holders to prevent damage
- Professional grading: Consider certification for valuable specimens
- Market research: Stay informed about current pricing trends
- Authentication: Verify authenticity, especially for error coins
- Timing: Monitor market conditions for optimal selling opportunities
Red Flags and Common Mistakes
Avoid these common pitfalls when dealing with 1999 Susan B Anthony dollars:
- Cleaning coins: Never clean coins as this destroys value
- Improper handling: Always handle coins by their edges
- Unrealistic expectations: Most examples are worth modest premiums
- Fake errors: Be cautious of artificially created “errors”
- Overgrading: Raw coins are often overestimated in grade
Conclusion
The 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar coin value encompasses a fascinating range of possibilities, from modest premiums for circulated examples to substantial values for perfect specimens and rare errors. While most examples trade for small premiums over face value, exceptional coins can command hundreds or even thousands of dollars.
Whether you’re a casual collector who discovered a 1999 Susan B. Anthony dollar in pocket change or a serious numismatist building a comprehensive collection, understanding these value factors helps you make informed decisions. Remember that condition, rarity, and market demand all play crucial roles in determining final values.
For anyone suspecting they own a valuable 1999 Susan B Anthony dollar, professional evaluation remains the best path forward. Certified grading services and experienced dealers can provide accurate assessments and help you understand your coin’s true market position in this intriguing corner of American numismatics.
What is a 1999 proof Susan B Anthony dollar coin?
Anthony Dollar. These are the final coins of the Anthony dollar series re-issued for one year only – 1999 ! Not only is this the last Proof Anthony dollar of the 20th century, but it represents the very first return of a coin series after so long an interruption – 18 years!