It’s important to clarify the type of coin being referred to. There are two primary possibilities when discussing a “John Tyler coin” from the period 1841-1845:
- Seated Liberty Dollar (minted between 1841-1845): These were the circulating dollar coins during John Tyler’s presidency. Their value depends heavily on their condition and rarity. According to the NGC Price Guide, as of August 2025:
– An 1841 Seated Liberty Dollar in circulated condition is worth between $350 and $2,850.
– An 1845 Seated Liberty Dollar in circulated condition is worth between $400 and $4,000.
– Pristine, uncirculated 1841 Silver Dollars can sell for as much as $125,000.
- John Tyler Presidential Dollar (minted in 2009): This is a modern commemorative coin issued as part of the Presidential $1 Coin series, honoring John Tyler’s presidency. The value of these coins also varies based on condition and whether they are circulated or uncirculated:
– Circulated coins are typically worth $1–$2.
– Uncirculated coins (MS60–MS66) can sell for $3–$25.
– High-grade uncirculated coins (MS67+) may reach $1,000.
– Some online listings offer circulated 2009 John Tyler Presidential Dollars for prices ranging from $200-$345, and even higher for those marketed as “rare” (potentially in the range of $1200-$2000).
– The [Littleton Coin Company] sells uncirculated 2009-P John Tyler Presidential Dollars for $6.25.
– US State Quarters sells them for $2.75.
In summary: To determine the worth of your “John Tyler coin,” you first need to identify whether it’s an authentic Seated Liberty Dollar from the 1840s or a 2009 Presidential Dollar. For an accurate valuation, it’s recommended to consult a professional coin appraiser or a reputable coin grading service.
How much is a $1 coin from 1841 worth?
According to the NGC Price Guide, as of August 2025, a Seated Liberty Dollar from 1841 in circulated condition is worth between $350 and $2850. However, on the open market 1841 Silver Dollars in pristine, uncirculated condition sell for as much as $125000.
What dollar coin is from 1841-1845?
John tyler dollar coin 1841-1845.
Are President $1 coins worth anything today?
So Where’s the Value? Despite its background, coin collectors can still get a big return from buying Presidential Dollars. Although most are worth no more than a few dollars, some are worth hundreds or thousands of dollars — and a couple are worth $100,000 and above.