The value of a 1905 one-cent coin, specifically an Indian Head Penny, depends heavily on its condition (grade) and color (toning).
Here’s a breakdown of approximate values for a 1905 Indian Head Cent (Philadelphia mint, no mint mark):
- Good-4 (G-4): $2 – $3
- Fine-12 (F-12): $5 – $7
- Extremely Fine-40 (XF-40): $10 – $16
- About Uncirculated-50 (AU-50): $20 – $36
The values for uncirculated coins are further affected by their color, often categorized as Brown (BN), Red-Brown (RB), or Red (RD). Red coins generally command the highest prices.
- MS-60:
– Brown (BN): $40 – $50
– Red-Brown (RB): $55 – $60
– Red (RD): $60 – $75
- MS-63:
– Brown (BN): $60 – $90
– Red-Brown (RB): $75 – $135
– Red (RD): $160 – $165
- MS-65:
– Brown (BN): $140 – $200
– Red-Brown (RB): $200 – $250
– Red (RD): $650 – $675
- MS-66:
– Brown (BN): $375 – $475
– Red-Brown (RB): $850
– Red (RD): $1,600 – $1,700
- MS-67:
– Brown (BN): Scarce
– Red-Brown (RB): Scarce
– Red (RD): $17,000+
Proof coins were specially made for collectors and have a much lower mintage, making them rarer and generally more valuable.
- PR-63:
– Brown (BN): $275 – $285
– Red-Brown (RB): $350
– Red (RD): $350
- PR-65:
– Brown (BN): $650
– Red-Brown (RB): $625
– Red (RD): $1,150
- PR-67:
– Brown (BN): $3,000+
– Red-Brown (RB): $5,150+
– Red (RD): $8,000 – $11,750+
- Rarity: Coins with lower mintages, like the proof 1905 Indian Head Cent, are typically more valuable.
- Condition (Grade): Coins in better condition, with less wear and original luster, fetch higher prices.
- Color (Toning): The amount of original red color remaining on the coin’s surface significantly impacts its value, especially for uncirculated specimens.
- Minting Errors: Rare errors can make a coin unique and highly desirable to collectors, according to brandywinepointe.com.
Note: The prices listed above are approximate and can fluctuate based on market demand and other factors. For a precise valuation, it’s recommended to consult a professional coin dealer or appraiser.
What makes a 1905 penny valuable?
The most valuable 1905 Indian Head cents are uncirculated coins earning the highest “Mint State” ratings from certified coin grading services. Mint State (uncirculated) coins are graded from MS-60 to MS-70.
Are coins from 1905 worth anything?
Great question! According to the NGC Price Guide, as of August 2025, a Liberty Head Nickel from 1905 in circulated condition is worth between $1.50 and $100. However, on the open market 1905 Nickels in pristine, uncirculated condition sell for as much as $6250.
Are any 1 cent US coins valuable?
Valuable pennies include rare key dates, error coins, and those with high silver or copper content. The 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent is one of the most valuable, often worth thousands of dollars due to its low mintage.